Strategic alignment alone doesn’t prove a project still deserves its funding. An early portfolio review tests each investment against business value, delivery capacity and the capabilities the future state requires.
Key Insights:
- Review the portfolio at around the 30% mark.
- Test what each project contributes, not just its alignment.
- Feed review findings into future investment planning.
An early project portfolio review helps leaders check whether they’re still investing in the right projects and whether those investments support the organisation’s strategy. Reviewing the portfolio at around the 30% mark gives them an opportunity to identify problems early and make adjustments before they start affecting delivery.
A well-defined future-state enterprise architecture shows what capabilities the business needs to deliver its strategy. A practical investment and delivery roadmap then helps leaders work out which projects to prioritise and in what order.
Once those projects get underway, leaders need to keep checking whether the original investment decisions still make sense. Business priorities may have changed since the portfolio was approved, or delivery teams may have uncovered dependencies that weren’t apparent during planning. Some projects may no longer justify the investment originally allocated to them.
There’s a well-established principle in project delivery that the early stages can have a significant bearing on the outcome. A Setup for Success Review within the first six weeks can help identify problems while there’s still time to address them.
Why the 30% mark suits a portfolio review
An unoptimised project portfolio can quickly create problems as projects compete for the same resources. Ideally, leaders will have already undertaken project portfolio optimisation and prioritisation to manage these competing demands. However, particularly in larger organisations, they need to keep reviewing those decisions as delivery progresses.
A portfolio that looked well-balanced three or four months ago may no longer make as much sense. Business priorities can change, while unexpected dependencies or resource constraints can affect what the organisation can realistically deliver. Some projects may have lost their strategic relevance, while others may no longer support the capabilities the business needs for its intended future state.
The costs can start to add up. As teams come under pressure, quality can suffer and delays can put further strain on budgets.
The 30% mark provides a useful opportunity to take stock. By then, leaders have enough evidence from delivery to see where problems are emerging but still have time to do something about them. Review too early and there may be little to go on. Leave it too late and the organisation may have already committed significant resources to projects that need rethinking.
When strategic alignment isn’t enough
Strategic alignment matters when reviewing a project portfolio, but leaders also need to look at what each project actually contributes to the business. Not every project will directly support a long-term strategic goal. Some address immediate operational needs, and that’s a valid reason to invest in them, even if their longer-term strategic value is limited.
A project can also tick the box for strategic alignment while working against the broader interests of the business. Take an organisation focused on reducing costs. A project might deliver savings in one area but compromise customer service in the process, potentially affecting revenue. On paper, it supports the cost reduction objective. In practice, it could leave the business less profitable.
A strategic PMO can help leaders look beyond individual projects and assess the trade-offs across the portfolio. They can examine the overall return on investment and whether the organisation has the capacity to deliver what it has committed to.
Future-state architecture brings another consideration into the picture: are the projects underway actually building the capabilities the business will need to achieve its longer-term strategy? Even where the business case remains sound, changes elsewhere in the portfolio may affect when a project should proceed or what needs to happen before it can succeed.
Questions for your next portfolio review
These questions can help leaders assess their current portfolio:
- Are we still investing in projects that support our three-to-five-year strategy? Can we show how the work underway contributes to our intended future state?
- Are we building the business capabilities we need? Are our current projects addressing the gaps identified in our future-state architecture?
- Do we understand how projects depend on each other? Have we identified architectural constraints or dependencies that could affect delivery?
- Can we still justify every funded project? Does each investment have a clear business driver, whether strategic, regulatory or operational, including resilience requirements?
- Do we have the capacity to deliver what we’ve committed to? Can we respond to changing priorities or unexpected requirements without putting existing projects at risk?
- Are the right specialists involved in these decisions? Do enterprise architects and delivery specialists have a meaningful say in portfolio reviews and investment decisions?
If the answers raise concerns, leaders need to decide whether to change their investment priorities or rethink the order in which projects are delivered.
Using portfolio review findings to guide future investment
A Setup for Success Portfolio Review can help leaders identify where they need to act now to improve portfolio performance. They may need to pause projects that no longer justify their investment or rethink delivery priorities to free up resources for more pressing work.
The findings can also help organisations make better investment decisions in the future. Investment committees can use what they’ve learned to examine proposed projects more closely, particularly where capability gaps or architectural dependencies could affect delivery. The PMO can then apply those insights to future portfolio planning and governance.
Even when a review confirms that projects are progressing as expected, it provides valuable assurance that the portfolio remains on track. As business priorities evolve, regular reviews help leaders make informed decisions about where to continue investing and where to change course, keeping the organisation moving towards its intended future state.
Quay Consulting is a professional services business specialising in the project landscape, transforming strategy into fit-for-purpose delivery. Meet our team or reach out to have a discussion today.